Case 869: In 1961, off the coast of New South Wales, Australia, a deckhand was bitten on the neck by a four-foot-long dog shark. Eyewitness accounts vary: Some say the deckhand was clowning with the shark aboard ship; others say he fell overboard and was immediately bitten. To release the victim, rescue workers were required to cut off the shark's head and open its jaws with a pair of pliers.
Case 1569: In 1967, while diving for abalone near Bird Rock in Bodega Bay, California, a scuba diver was seized by a shark that latched on to the left side of his body from the shoulder to below the waist. It took 200 stitches to close the multiple puncture wounds.
Lots of data, slim on trends
The best of the shark stories are summarized in Shark Attack, a 1974 book (now out-of-print) by H. David Baldridge, one of the original leaders of the International Shark Attack File project. While it makes for good reading, it does little to build confidence for those of us who enjoy spending time in the sea.
Furthermore, considering all the time and money the Navy spent gathering data, Baldridge's analysis of the attacks--in particular, his failure to report many meaningful trends among the 1,652 cases--is exceptionally weak.
For instance, Baldridge notes that 62 percent of all shark attacks in the Navy's file occurred in less than five feet of water. That's statistically significant, and might inspire some of us to spend the summer swimming in deeper channels, farther from shore. But Baldridge also points out that the vast majority of waders and bathers are found in shallow water. So, naturally, that's where most of the shark encounters would take place.
Baldridge also reports that the vast majority of attacks took place in the mid-afternoon. Does that mean we should limit our swim times to the morning or evening hours? Afraid not--later research has revealed these to be the most dangerous times off the day. Baldridge's midday statistic merely reflects the time when the majority of divers, beachgoers, and boaters are in the water.
While they run short on useful tips for regular folks seeking to avoid shark attacks, some of Baldridge's findings are outright amusing. He dismisses a San Francisco newspaper reporter's assertion that two-piece bikini bathing suits are especially attractive to marauding sharks, but does concur that sharks are drawn to what other researchers have dubbed Yum-Yum Yellow—the day-glo hue of most life rafts and emergency gear. (Note: More recent analysis of the International Shark Attack File contradicts this rather Edward Gorey-like assertion, since nearly a fourth of the divers attacked by great white sharks were wearing drab blue and black suits.)
Playing the numbers game
So what advice or guidance can we give people who spend their summer vacations on the shores of shark-inhabited seas?
Since Baldrige's days, the International Shark Attack File has nearly doubled in size. Now managed by George Burgess, a professor at the University of Florida in Gainesville, the file contains updates on more than 3,300 cases. No longer housed in a mainframe computer or managed by punch-card-wielding nerds, the file's data is accessible on the Florida Museum of Natural History's Web site, along with a series of summary pages, helpful charts, and graphs.
One of the most interesting pages of the site weighs the relative risk of being chomped by a shark with that of being bitten by dogs, cats, hamsters, horses, squirrels, and, yes, humans. In all cases, these other incidents far outweigh shark attacks. But of course, they get considerably less attention from the media.
In fact, more people die each year from falling coconuts than from shark bites, says Burgess, who likes to play the numbers game at least as much as Baldridge did.
Since 1876, there have been 254 confirmed unprovoked attacks on humans by great white sharks, 67 of which were fatal, Burgess says. Over the same time period, there have been 83 tiger shark attacks, resulting in 29 fatalities. Bull sharks have attacked 69 times with 17 fatalities.
That's not a lot, especially compared to the numbers of fatalities among people driving to and from the beach, adds Burgess. "We must realize whenever we enter the ocean, we're not in a bathtub or wading pool--it's never 100 percent safe."